Why not come and help build the workspace on FutureNHS
Individuals facing multiple disadvantage are entangled in a complex web of challenges that stem from a convergence of factors, including poverty, trauma, and discrimination. Weight stigma perpetuates and magnifies health disparities in already marginalised populations (Shaw, Meadows 2022). Weight stigma, a pervasive form of prejudice and discrimination based on body size, stands as a significant factor that further complicates the lives of those already facing multiple disadvantages.
This article aims to shed light on the intricate relationship between weight stigma and multiple disadvantage, advocating for comprehensive interventions that promote wellbeing and address the underlying social determinants of health, independent of weight change.
Understanding Weight Stigma and Its Impact
Weight stigma manifests in various forms, including verbal and nonverbal cues, jokes, bullying, social exclusion, and even denial of healthcare. It perpetuates harmful stereotypes that associate higher weight with laziness, lack of willpower, and moral failings. These negative perceptions can lead to internalised weight stigma, where individuals adopt these harmful beliefs about themselves, resulting in decreased self-esteem, social isolation, and increased risk of depression and anxiety.
The consequences of weight stigma extend beyond the psychological realm. Individuals facing weight stigma often delay or avoid seeking healthcare due to fear of judgement, humiliation, or having any correlatory health need overlooked. This reluctance to engage with healthcare providers can lead to undiagnosed and untreated medical conditions, exacerbating existing health issues and hindering overall well-being.
The Interconnectedness of Multiple Disadvantage and Weight Stigma
Weight stigma does not operate in isolation; it intersects with other forms of discrimination, such as racism, sexism, and homophobia, creating a compounding effect that further marginalises individuals facing multiple disadvantage. For instance, individuals from Black and Asian communities are disproportionately affected by both weight stigma and other forms of discrimination, leading to a heightened risk of adverse health outcomes. Consider body image complexities that potentially impact non-binary or transitioning individuals more significantly, leading to exacerbated physical and mental health inequities.
The complex interplay between weight stigma and multiple disadvantage extends to socioeconomic factors as well. Individuals living in poverty often face poorer access to nutritious food, safe exercise spaces, and healthcare access, further perpetuating the cycle of disadvantage.
Health: Beyond Weight Change Culture
Addressing weight stigma and its intersection with multiple disadvantage requires a holistic approach that reduces individual blame, and focuses on cohesive action, within the community, and shifts societal bias. It is crucial to recognise that changes in physical activity, balancing nutrition, alcohol consumption, and smoking cessation can significantly improve public health outcomes, independent of weight change. (Matheson 2012)
Physical Activity: Improving access to regular physical activity, regardless of body weight, has been shown to reduce the risk of chronic diseases, including heart disease, stroke, type 2 diabetes, and certain types of cancer. It also improves mental health, boosts self-esteem, and enhances overall quality of life. Create spaces and services where everyone feels welcome, safe and body weight / composition is not scrutinised or given as a goal.
Nutrition: Equitable access to nourishing food. For some lower income households in the UK; up to 77% of their income would need to be spent to meet basic nutritional guidelines. Weight change culture belies many eating disorders and disordered eating.
Reducing Alcohol Consumption: Unpressurised non-abstinence reduces stigma, and less alcohol improves sleep quality, reduces stress levels, enhances cognitive function.
Smoking Cessation: Weight neutral support to quit smoking - many people continue to smoke through weight gain fears. Quitting smoking is one of the most significant steps an individual can take to improve their health.
*
VCSE Nutriri is learning that 'permission for inconsistency' built into any service co-creates re-engagement; especially when a person might have long term health conditions and fluctuating capacity.
*
Combating Weight Stigma through Social Prescribing
Social prescribing, offers a clear avenue for addressing weight stigma and its intersection with multiple disadvantage. Social prescribing links individuals with non-clinical community resources and activities that address the underlying social, psychological, and environmental factors that contribute to health issues.
Can We Allocate Weight Management Budgets for Weight Neutral / Inclusive Social Prescribing Initiatives…
Integrating social prescribing into strategies can effectively utilise existing 'weight management' budgets while addressing the broader determinants of health. Here's how weight management funds can be reallocated to support - weight neutral/inclusive - social prescribing initiatives:
Training and Development: Invest in training healthcare professionals and community workers on the principles and practices of weight neutral social prescribing, equipping them to identify and connect individuals with relevant community resources.
Cultural Sensitivity and Accessibility: Allocate resources to ensure that social prescribing services are culturally sensitive, accessible, and inclusive of individuals from diverse backgrounds and socioeconomic strata.
Community Resource Mapping: Allocate resources to map and develop a comprehensive inventory of community resources and activities that support weight neutral services, such as cooking classes, exercise programmes, peer support groups, and mental health counselling.
Partnership Building: Foster alliances with statutory bodies, community organisations, VCSE’s, charity, local care partnerships to expand the reach and understanding of social prescribing interventions.
Social Prescribing Link Workers: Fund the employment of social prescribing link workers, within PCN’s and VCSE, who act as navigators, connecting individuals with appropriate community resources, addressing barriers to access, and providing ongoing support.
Discussion
The stress from weight stigma is a significant factor that exacerbates the challenges faced by individuals experiencing multiple disadvantage. However, bias awareness training alongside improving access, encompassing physical activity, balanced nutrition, unpressurised alcohol and cigarette reduction, offers a comprehensive approach to improving public health, independent of weight change. By addressing the underlying social determinants of health, fostering inclusive communities, and empowering individuals to make informed choices about their health, we can create a society where everyone has more opportunity to thrive.
"Trust is a social determinant of health," Professor Bola Owolabi's keynote words resonated deeply at the Royal Society of Medicine Innovation for Inequalities event. The spectrum of inequities has multiple intersections, making body weight perhaps the most common point of bias across all characteristics, determinants and health groups.
For many of us navigating healthcare, trust can be a fragile thing. With up to 2/3rds of higher weight people delaying or withholding from healthcare altogether; VCSE Nutriri attends events to gather consensus for weight neutrality, share our innovations' progress and access support for what must come next.
Uninvited weight talk, even when well-intentioned, can chip away at trust, leaving behind feelings of shame and failure, which hinders open communication, disengages patients and undermines effective care, perpetuating health inequities.
VCSE Nutriri believes that weight-neutral approaches can not only improve patient experience but also lead to better health outcomes. We are actively seeking partners to conduct research on whether weight-neutral healthcare increases patient participation in other services, enhances their engagement rates, and ultimately, leads to improved health for all.
With 2 innovations ready for wider testing; our workforce Weight Neutral Training and our citizen focused Food & Body Ease curriculum hosted on the Co-Learning Hub - we look forward to connecting.
Links from poster: Links: Aphramor 2010 Bidstats 2023 Matheson 2012 Muennig 2008 OHID 21/22 WMS Ryan et al. 2022 Shaw, Meadows 2022 Theis, White 2021 Nutriri - Core20PLUS Ambassador Nutriri - FutureNHS
The theme of the event, "Tackling Inequalities through Innovation and Entrepreneurship," not only encouraged our attendance, it resulted in this ⬆️ poster submission from Nutriri too "Navigating the Labyrinth of Multiple Disadvantage: Harnessing Social Prescription to Combat Weight Stigma."
We felt at home amongst Lived - Living Experience and Patient-Driven solutions being heralded as critical for building a more equitable healthcare system. Well aligned to VCSE Nutriri’s mission of moving beyond "weight talk" towards weight-neutral approaches in order to enhance existing and new services in outdated ‘weight management’ and ‘slimming club’ spaces.
A summary of the day:
Key theme: Collaboration across specialties is crucial to address health inequalities.
NHS England's Core20PLUS5 approach: Emphasizes equitable access and uptake of healthcare innovations.
Keynote speakers:
Prof. Bola Owolabi - Trust is key for equitable access and uptake.
Kaakpema "KP" Yelpaala - Equitable innovation requires intentionality and participation from marginalised communities.
Prof. Kevin Fong - Change takes time and pressure, but we must keep going.
Success stories: Presentations from Core20PLUS5 sites and innovative NHS Clinical Entrepreneur Programme graduates.
We left the London event hopeful of more people being ‘a bit more Elvis’ - with a little less conversation and a little more action!
The Annual International Weight Stigma Conference is an inter-disciplinary event that brings together scholars and practitioners from a range of backgrounds (e.g., public health, government and public policy, psychology, medicine, sociology, anthropology, allied health professions, education, sports and exercise science, social sciences, media studies, business, law, activism, and the lay public) to consider research, policy, rhetoric, and practice around the issue of weight stigma.
The two-day interdisciplinary programme covers the entire weight stigma research spectrum – from basic, to applied, to clinical, to policy – and feature an outstanding roster of international speakers and local experts.
Contributions from across a wide range of disciplines and methodological and theoretical approaches. Intersectional approaches and perspectives from marginalised groups.
The National Academy for Social Prescribing, the Social Prescribing Network and the University of Westminster hosted the 5th International Social Prescribing Conference.
Focusing on innovation in social prescribing, the conference offered a unique opportunity to share and discuss the latest advances and research in this field.
Innovation in Social Prescribing, including Arts, Nature, Heritage and Digital
Social Prescribing for Children and Young People
Tackling Health Inequalities Around The World
Supporting the Workforce; Training, Retention and Progression
Breaking out of primary care; Whole system approaches
Evidence and Evaluation; Data, Demand and Efficacy
Health Inequalities and Major Conditions
The Future of Social Prescribing
The fantastic line-up of speakers and panellists included
Professor Sir Michael Marmot
Professor Dame Helen Stokes-Lampard
Cormac Russell
Dr William Bird
Professor Sir Muir Gray
Dr Radha Modgil
Dr Marie Polley
Gay Palmer
Dame Sarah Mullally (Bishop of London)
Dr Tara Mastracci
Dr Michael Dixon
Prof Gan Wee Hoe, CEO of SingHealth Community Hospitals, Singapore
Isabelle Wachsmuth, World Health Organization
and a wide range of leaders and academics from the UK and around the world.
A conference designed for healthcare professionals, researchers, policy makers, community leaders, commissioners, link workers and students – and anyone with an interest in social prescribing.
We must ask ourselves, 'what is the difference that will make the difference this time?'.
We know that the answer isn't as simple as diet and exercise. We need to:
take a whole family approach to health and wellbeing;
think beyond what's possible; and
turn our minds to the groundbreaking and radical solutions.
Only then will we be able to revolutionise health and wellbeing for all.
VCSE Nutriri was thrilled to be hosted by BOOST and NATIONAL VOICES
Our trip up to LOC in the Lakes was an opportunity to express what the theme 'The Weight Is Over' means to Nutriri... quite simply we interpreted this as 'the focus on weight (as a useful health metric) can now finally be over'
Part of the day saw us hosting a vibrant group of 15, who shared their lived / working experience as clinicians working in 'weight management' - we heard their frustrations of having their skilled practice 'held back' by outdated measures and KPI's - and together we came up with ideas and actions of what must come next!
Bringing together health, social care and community leaders from across UK who are interested in population health and equity to share ideas, examples of good practice, and start to plan practical steps that we can all take to keep driving action for prevention, improving quality and safety, tackling inequalities, and most importantly for putting communities and staff at the heart of change efforts. Find out more.